“Rules Were Made to Be Broken”. The funny thing about clichés
is the definition and the reality. The dictionary says “an overused expression.
I say it is a time tested and proven truth. This is a
cliché that I have never subscribed to until recently.
In the world of marketing, I have created my own set of
rules and rarely break them. The reason is simple. Just about every time I see
someone else break one of them, failure follows. Why these failures occur so
often is simple. All of my rules are based on observation. That means they are
real and in turn reliable. You see, I monitor them on a regular basis and if
one changes, I change the rule. Endemic to the process is reality. You see they
are not based on my judgment, my opinion or my brilliance; they are simply based
on my observations.
Given that, I rarely break them myself or see my own rules
broken by others with success. I however will share a rare one with you today.
In doing so, I will further invite you to break this rule because I have
recently done so myself.
The rule I am referring to is this. The perfect pathway to a
favorable purchase decision has three steps.
1)
Get the target consumers attention to your
Selling Proposition.
2)
Immediately communicate your Brand accompanied
by your generic Descriptor.
3)
Move them next to your Benefit, accompanied by
your strongest Attribute Drivers.
Those three steps need a great deal of explanation that I
have detailed in my book “Pull” and in several other blogs but will skip here
today.
Notice two things about these three steps. First, the
leading communication is the Brand name, which I say should have lots of
character and be short, poetic and memorable. Secondly, the Benefit is third on
my list of steps and is accompanied by its Attribute Drivers. This scenario is
almost always an integral part of all marketing recommendations I make to my
clients.
Here is a break in that scenario that can work. It is
creating a brand name that is in itself a Benefit. This sounds easy but is so
easy to screw up that I recommend you not try it because it will backfire on
you far more often than it will work.
Way back in my early days, I was working with Bill Gross,
the genius behind Knowledge Adventure, children’s educational software. At that
time, a brand called Reader Rabbit was dominating the category. The assumption
was that a rabbit would make it fun for kids to learn. It worked, until we launched
Bills product entry in that category, Jump Start Kindergarten. Jump Start
simply trumped the Reader Rabbit positioning by communicating that it will give
your kid an advantage over the other kids. The rabbit died a sudden and just
death at the hands of Jump Start and the Jump Start line continues to flourish
to this date.
In all honesty, I did not realize it at the time but Jump
Start was a benefit incorporated into the Brand name. Even if you think real
hard, you are unlikely to identify many others. I can think only of four. One I
have been familiar with for over ten years is “Move Free”. Move Free is a nutritional
supplement that simply has Glucosamine and MSM to help relieve the symptoms
associated with worn out joints and is a very unremarkable product. It is a
formula that has been around for many years. It is however a very successful
product and I think its naming has been a significant factor. As I look back at
it, knowing who named it, I am reasonably sure it was done without the benefit
of this observation…in other words, probably lucky.
There is one more. I am very proud to share that I was
instrumental in the launch of two very successful Arm & Hammer laundry
detergent products a few months back and one of them belongs in this blog. They
are targeted to two very different and unique users. One, “Crystal Burst”, is
targeted to sophisticated users and the other, “Toss N’ Done”, is targeted to
people like me who just want to get it over with. Toss N’ Done is the benefit.
It’s about me, not the product.
Of these four examples, I created two and I love that I did.
By the way, KUDOS to all those who helped me do it. I’m a very lucky dude who
gets to work with great people.
Having said all that, here is why you may not want to try
this. If you screw this up it will backfire on you. Benefits are very sensitive
for target consumers. Without the accompanying Attribute Driver, they are often
considered fluff and dismissed by target consumers. Dismissed means NO
SALE. If you have the luxury of research, go for it. If not, this is a trap and
it will nail you. Remember, humans are looking for what is wrong and fluff will
feed into that characteristic. Without research you will never know until you
launch it. Asking all your employees and friends is not research, in case you
were headed in that direction.
So, do what you will, but watch out for the traps.
Good Luck and let me know if you do.
Cheers,
Keith Chambers
Keynote Marketing Speaker
Creative Marketing Consultant
(310) 473-0010
www.chambersgroup.com
follow my blog by clicking one of the links below